Form, Function, Neo-Classicism and Icon:
The Evolution of the Heinz Ketchup Bottle
8/29/1997

---------------------- Information from the mail header -----------------------


Sender:       Museum discussion list MUSEUM-L@HOME.EASE.LSOFT.COM
Poster:       "Robert A. Baron"
Subject:      Re: Ketchup Revision
Posted:       8/29/97
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

At 10:28 AM 8/29/97 -0400, Barry Dressel wrote:

>I'm reading Thomas Pynchon's new novel "Mason and Dixon" ; the two
>surveyors are in Capetown, South Africa to observe the transit of Venus,
>and Dixon discovers Malay food (Malays brought to SA by the Dutch)
>including a sauce called jetlap. At one point they are having trouble
>getting it out of the bottle and a character suggests slapping the bottom
>of the bottle....

"Form, Function, Neo-Classicism and Icon: The Evolution and Meaning of the Heinz Ketchup Bottle."  A synopsis:

The shape of the Ketchup bottle is derived (ultimately) from Attic vase types of the fifth and sixth centuries B.C.  Both the Alabastron and the Lekythos, for practical (functional) reasons, may have contributed to the shape of the long-necked Ketchup bottle.  Both were used to hold precious liquids like perfume.  Their restricted opening kept the entire contents from coming out at once.  Unlike the Alabastron, the Lekythos had a long thin neck, so that, like the Ketchup bottle, the flow of liquid was modulated by the bubble of air that had to make its way through the fluid to the bottom end of the neck of the up-turned vessel.

I don't know what consistency was given to the early Ketchup sauce, but it seems clear to me that the shape of the bottle was chosen only in part because it functioned to modulate the flow of liquid.  The classical allusion to container shapes (especially the lekythos, which was seen abundantly on Greek funerary art) was underscored by the Heinz company using a shape which also alluded to fluted Doric columns.  At that time these classical allusions were of particular importance since they tended to confer the notions of acceptability and quality to the product. The identifiable vessel shape, combined with the fluting, served to create an iconic shape for Heinz's Ketchup which has been used subsequently to signal the connection of other products to the original one, e.g. Heinz Chili Sauce (which uses a wide necked shape).

Furthermore, as new methods of dispensing Ketchup have been developed (notably the plastic squeeze bottle), and as new giant-sized bottles have been introduced, the main characteristics of the original shape (no longer functional) have remained as reference points: the long neck and the fluted perimeter profile. These still work to identify these products with high quality and to promote brand identification and, in a curious way, serve to migrate several small elements of the Classical Tradition into modern times.

There are some lessons for students of art history here.  In the case of the Ketchup (or catsup) bottle, the shape is so closely allied to the product that without labels any American can easily identify the contents of any traditional catsup bottle.  Shapes not only have functions, they have associations.  Further, without labels, anyone can identify the Heinz bottle.  As any student of the art history of Western culture knows, traditional iconography and traditional forms are closely wedded together, it is quite possible, in fact, that iconography and form are functions of each other.

Robert Baron
(Next will be a small article on our proposed reconstruction of the "Statue of Liberty" out of ash-tray shards.
12/02: On the Statue of Liberty Reconstruction, see the Publish and Perish Journal.)

Images:
Top: Lekythos with woman and maid, Achilles Painter, c. 450 - 440 B.C., Boston, Museum of Fine Arts (Richter, Handbook, # 453.)
Middle: Heinz Ketchup Bottle predating architectural metaphor. Note pickle logo. Photo by a donor whose name I have forgotten. Hopefully he will find his photo and identify himself.
Bottom: Heinz Squeeze Ketchup Bottle. Plastic.

> >----------
>> From: Chuck Watkins watkinsca@APPSTATE.EDU
>> To: MUSEUM-L@HOME.EASE.LSOFT.COM
>> Subject: Re: Ketchup Revision
>> Date: 29 August 1997 10:08 >>
>> Dear Robert,
>> Love the title of the lecture.  If you have not already published it,
>> why not send the manuscript to the Winterthur Portfolio, which is
>> always looking for good material culture articles?
>> Regards,
>> Chuck Watkins
>>
>> Robert A. Baron wrote:
>> >
>> > Some day I should put on paper my lecture entitled
>> > "Form, Function, Neo-Classicism and Icon: The Evolution of the Heinz
>> > Ketchup Bottle,"
>> > but I think the title says it all.
>> >
>> > r.baron
>> >
>>
>> --
>> Dr. Charles A. Watkins
>> Appalachian Cultural Museum
>> Appalachian State University
>> Boone, NC
>> 704/262-3117
>> email: watkinsca@appstate.edu
>> http://www.museum.appstate.edu >


Ketchup was sold in the 1830s as medicine.

Home Page | E-mail Index